Sunday, 8 February 2015

A Tough Pill to Swallow

Just as I began questioning if my new way to teach math (no textbooks, problem-based learning) was working, a student gave me a Christmas card with the following written in it:


This made my day!  Maybe my year! "Yes, I am SO happy you no longer HATE math!" I thought. To have a 7th grader write this to me, made me think realize that what I was doing was working.

This past summer, I got a chance to rewrite the math curriculum using only online resources, math videos that I created and current resources that I had.  I decided that I could create a better curriculum than the current math book we were using.  I was hopeful and fearful about what other teachers, parents and especially my students would think.  I like to think that I use a blended practice of current math practices and problem based learning.  This type of learning can be hard for students because they are used to the "kill and drill" method, not really having to think and maybe even failing a few times before they come to the correct answer.  Students were frustrated and mad, would shut down at times but I kept pushing.......I knew that this type of learning was better for understanding and retention.  I actually heard out of the mouths of some of my students......wait for it.............."This type of math was fun!" *GASP!* Yes, they really said it.

Robert Kaplinsky has great ideas about how to run a problem-based classroom and is a great resource to use.  He uses the element of surprise as the hook and kids love to see if they can get the right answer.  I was lucky enough to see him speak in person and I will tell you as, a math teacher, if you have the chance, you MUST go!  He really gets you motivated.

I am not saying that every student loves it or feels the same way as the one above but this is the motivation I needed to keep pushing my students and myself to try something new.  How can I ask my students to try something new if I am not willing?  How can any of us?  I need to be learning side by side with my students, showing them what lifelong learning looks like.  I can't be afraid to try new things or fail or be worried what people might say.  If these are the lessons I am trying to teach my students in middle school, I need to take and live my own advice.  It's a tough pill to swallow sometimes but I have to hand it to a student to bring it to my attention.

-Melissa

Friday, 6 February 2015

Podcast: Idea Showcase and EdCampSTL



In this episode, we talk about the Idea Showcase, our new 3D Printer and EdCampSTL. Listeners can subscribe to the podcast on iTunes. Search iTunes for Harmonized Learning in the podcast section and click "subscribe". You can also follow us on Twitter @melissahellwig4 and @dayankee

Educational Readings for Creative Educators - assessment,maths,creativitym and overworked teachers.....



By Allan Alach


I welcome suggested articles, so if you come across a gem, email it to me at allan.alach@ihug.co.nz.

This week’s homework!

How long before administrators lose touch with the realities of the classroom?
Principals lose touch?
A good question…
“In closing, are administrators who are freshly out of the classroom better at evaluating teachers since they are recently removed? Or, are these new administrators stuck in their offices dealing with school discipline while the more senior administrator, who is further removed from the classroom, handles most of the classroom observations?”

Causing educational damage!
Why Is This So Hard?
Ruminations on the problems of convincing people about the damage caused by testing policies.
“But I cannot wrap my head around how any system of standardized testing, which was designed during the Eugenics movement to sort and track people according to race, class, and gender can possibly offer the solution to the persons and groups it was intended to harm the most.”

How Strict Is Too Strict?: The backlash against no-excuses discipline in high school
Is this crazy or what?
“In step with an energetic breed of charter advocates nationally, the reformers who descended on New Orleans were convinced that progressive pedagogy and discipline had an especially sorry record in low-income districts, where many children faced more than their share of disorder and
violence. Chaotic classrooms, the newcomers argued, were a major reason schools floundered and failed. The controversial broken-windows theory—which holds that a firm response to minor signs of disarray, like broken windows, is essential to inhibiting more-serious criminal activity—was the reigning analogy, invoked by top administrators on down. No infraction was too small to address.”

Allowing students to deeply understand assessment.
Hmmm, I like the approach but not the use of rubrics that turn learning into the educational version of paint by numbers.
“It was interesting observing students move through the class. Once they realized how different each chart was, they became absorbed in reading the charts, giving feedback and then, unexpectedly commenting on the feedback and observations being made.
As you read, notice how the students have internalized our classroom discourse.”

5 Things Teachers Wish Parents Knew
Thanks to Stephen Baker for this one. What would you add/delete/change?
“Reading all these responses from teachers was a great reminder to me, just how important it is to be PRESENT when you are with your kids. Pay attention to what they enjoy and make their schoolwork a priority. Teachers have such a short amount of time to give your children all the skills they need, so you HAVE to help. “

A must read!
 Learn math without fear, Stanford expert says

“Stanford Professor Jo Boaler says that students most effectively learn "math facts" working on problems that they enjoy, rather than through exercises and drills they fear. Speed pressure, timed testing and blind memorization damage children's experience of math, she says”.

Peter Senge
What You Need for a Caring Classroom: Daniel Goleman and Peter Senge outline three kinds of empathy kids need for success at work and in life. 
“A new article in Scientific American, "The Secret to Raising Smart Kids," suggests that "focusing on 'process,' rather than intelligence or talent, produces high achievers in school and in life." This process consists of personal effort and effective strategies. One process we are talking about today is building empathy into the classroom setting, and how developing emotional intelligence is key to success inside and outside of the classroom.”

It’s time ministers realised that teachers really do want to teach
Thanks to Joce Jesson for this link.
“Children are measured at an ever more granular level, to a narrowing set of performance indicators. It is fundamentally disrespectful to them, a cynical waste of their time for the purposes
of political point-scoring.
This misunderstands the nature of learning: that individuals do different things at different rates, and the speed of one individual’s learning can vary wildly, without being anybody’s fault.”


This week’s contributions from Bruce Hammonds:

Why Preschool Shouldn’t Be Like School
Lets not lose imp of play!
“New research shows that teaching kids more and more, at ever-younger ages, may backfire. Ours is an age of pedagogy. Anxious parents instruct their children more and more, at younger and younger ages, until they're reading books to babies in the womb. They pressure teachers to make kindergartens and nurseries more like schools.”



New Zealand Creativity Challenge 2015
This looks like it will be very good.
‘… the event will include hands-on workshops, discussion groups and excellent networking opportunities.
“We want to create something that will have an inspiring and vigorous life long after the conference itself is over. We want to connect people across different fields, such as the arts,
science, business and education.
“The Challenge theme is ‘Creativity Crosses Boundaries’ because it’s time to move beyond the age of super heroes and understand that we’re all in this together. Certainly we need some experts and heroes but creativity belongs to everyone – it is central to our humanity.”’
http://bit.ly/1AgU22a

Is YOUR School Wasting Money on Technology?
A very good question, posed by Bill Ferriter…. Reminds me of an old cliche - Any teacher who can be replaced by technology, should be replaced.
“He calls us "ever-optimistic techno-cheerleaders" -- blinded by the belief that if we JUST had more gizmos and gadgets and connections to the web, we could do wonderful things with our kids.  The truth, however, is that communities have gotten no REAL returns on the investments that they have made in classroom technologies.  We keep spending millions on everything from iPads to IWBs to 3D printers yet our schools remain places where learners stagnate.”

Can Students Have Too Much Tech?
In a similar vein …
“To the extent that such a teacher can benefit from classroom technology, he or she should get it. But only when such teachers are effectively trained to apply a specific application to teaching a particular topic to a particular set of students — only then does classroom technology really work. Even then, we still have no proof that the newly acquired, tech-centric skills that students learn in the classroom transfer to novel problems that they need to solve in other areas.”

How To Do Everything Right In Schools.
Bruce’s comment: Develop a culture of intellectual inquiry in your school, or class. A short but insightful read.
“Begin with a theory, make a prediction, test, observe, modify the theory, and so on. Fields from astronomy to medicine have used this process. The fact that education as a field has not universally embraced this process is one reason it remains vulnerable to fads and fashions. This is where the role of school and district leaders comes in. It’s up to those leaders to establish a culture of intellectual inquiry, one that values mistakes for what they teach us about what we might try next rather than one that uses mistakes as a reason to punish others. This certainly runs contrary to the way some education leaders have been trained to operate.”

What attitudes towards learning have your students brought with them - what will need to change?
Bruce’s latest blog posting, making suggestions for New Zealand teachers reflect on at the end
of their first week of the 2015 school year.
“Negotiating with your students to develop ownership is always a good idea. It would be interesting to ask your class to list and then share the things they would like to learn about, the things that concern them and the things they wonder about.  Teachers who have done this have found that their students study ideas align well with the suggestions of the curriculum.”

Matching Tool To Task

Last week we wrote a grant on DonorsChoose.org for a 3D Printer. Within a couple of days, our students' families funded the grant so that we can use the printer to further the kids' learning. We have several students who are creating amazing projects who can use a 3D printer to advance their learning. This is the way things should be. The learning should drive the use of technology.

Too often we get technology and then try to find ways to use it. That is backwards. The way it should be is that the acquisition of technology should be a natural extension of the learning that is taking place. When we do things in that order, we are assured that the technology is relevant to the kids and their learning. As the school year evolves, we move in different directions depending on the interests and talents of our kids. Each group is different. In order to honor these differences, we plan our program according to the group of kids that we have. To that end, our technology needs vary from year to year. This year, one of our needs has been a 3D printer. We are ecstatic that we were able to get our grant funded and are eager to get the kids creating.



Wednesday, 4 February 2015

What attitudes towards learning have your students brought with them - what will need to change?

The first week of school has all but finished - tomorrow, Friday is Waitangi Day. Insightful teachers would have used the day to undertake a 'mini' unit on what the day stands for. If not then Monday
would be  good time to 'harvest' their thoughts - and clarify any misconceptions.

A good idea is to use the concept of a treaty to develop  the beginnings of a class treaty on good behaviours by both partners - the students and the teachers. Your ongoing success will depend on developing  respectful relationships.

What are the best behaviours of a successful learners?
What are best behaviours of a  good teacher?

During the first few days - more the first few minutes - your students will be carefully observing you to see what you stand for ( or even what they can getaway with!). It would be a good idea to discuss with the class your stance as a teacher - this will contribute to answering the above questions and will at least clarify your role as a teacher.

The first week or so is a good time to gather 'data' on the attitudes individual students have towards  learning area and any aspect of school you might want to know their views about. I saw this demonstrated by a teacher who went through it with the class as if she was there age. She let them know her strengths and weaknesses at the time and how she has improved on things since then.
Howard Gardner

If this were to be done the list of questions would be best drawn up by the teaching team - and latter repeated to see how things are changing. Students could answer on a five point scale going from 'I love it' to 'don't like it at all'.

You might like them to tell you how they think they learn - get them to consider something they learnt over the holidays. How do you get good at anything?

Attitudes make all the difference in learning but few teachers bother to gather such information.

At the beginning of the year is also a good time to find out what talents , or interests, your
Colour in the amount of your interest
students bring with them to class. Use  Howard Gardners concept of multiple intelligence to see what your students bring with them that you can capitalize on during the year.

Negotiating with your students to develop ownership is always a good idea. It would be interesting to ask your class to list and then share the things they would like to learn about, the things that concern them and the things they wonder about.  Teachers who have done this have found that their students study ideas align well with the suggestions of the curriculum.  Teachers can then include suggestions into the years programme.. Students could be helped by discussing the various strand of the Learning Areas of the New Zealand Curriculum

Another good idea is to , at the beginning of the day to go over the days programme and  just as importunately having a ten minute reflective period  at the end of the day to discuss the three things they achieved during the day. What did you do at school toady is the first questions many parents ask - it is a good idea to ensure students have a positive answer. Great PRO.

Although the holidays have passed it is not too late for your class to list the best things they did during their holidays and to select one to write about - as if they were there. If this is done model the process by sharing your experiences and elaborating the best thing. Sometimes small experiences - like catching a fish - provide the best ideas for powerful writing.

Is such a piece of focused personal writing is done then it could be written out ( after drafting and maybe discussion with you) in their best handwriting. This will give you an idea of the quality of their handwriting. Such writing could become a weekly task - drafted out Monday morning.

An illustration could be added to such a piece of writing. Many students have never been taught the skill of drawing and will need help. One again focus on the important aspect selected for their story - as if they were taking a photograph.

My own experience is that far too many students will arrive in your class thinking first finished is best. By 'slowing the ace of their work', by encouraging observational skills, by teaching them some simple formats to present their work you will slowly develop the id era if a thing is worth doing it is worth doing well.'

'Slowing the pace' gives the students time to think and you time help those in need.

Slowing the pace, learning to observe and trying to beat your own personal best, doing fewer things well will all make your class a more purposeful learning environment.

The above ideas , plus a few more, can be found in this link

Idea Showcase Reflections

Today we opened up our 20% Time projects for public comment. In the school cafeteria, for two hours, students, teachers, parents and administrators came in to see the project ideas. We call this the Idea Showcase, a chance for kids to talk about their project ideas with an authentic audience and answer questions about the projects that they may not have thought about before. Over a hundred spectators browsed the projects over the two hour block of time.

The kids really rose to the occasion. Many were not ready when they woke up this morning, but worked hard to polish their presentations and materials in time to be effective advocates for their project ideas. Watching the kids interact with the adult visitors was especially interesting. Kids often have difficulty talking to adults about their work, but today the kids seemed to be engaged and verbose about their ideas. They were really able to enter into discussions about learning, and what they hoped to accomplish, on a deeper level than many would expect.

The projects represent a vast array of ideas. These are the ideas that the kids really wanted to pursue. A conversation with one parent went something like this:

"When you guys first started this, I wasn't sure what you were doing. There didn't seem to be much direction for the kids," the parent said.

"That's true. We encourage but try not to steer at the beginning. The kids have to come up with their own idea," I replied.

"Well, we ran into some real roadblocks during the last few months. I figured that those were things she (her daughter) would have to deal with. She solved the problems but she wasn't really sure how to at first," mom said.

"Yes, that's exactly it! It has to be real-life learning. We don't know the solutions to a lot of the problems we face and we have to figure them out as best we can," I said.

"Well, looking around at the projects, I get it now. This is amazing. All of these project were the kids' ideas," she said.

"Yep, they are. It's different from the way we normally think of school. If I give a kid a paper to fill out with answers that I know are supposed to be there, then that is MY work, not the kids' work. But here, all of these ideas, this clearly is the kids' work," I said.

"That is so true. I look around and I'm surprised by what these kids are doing," she replied.

"We are surprised every year when we start 20% Time," I said.

The level of thinking and problem-solving that these kids demonstrated so far is astonishing. Several have tweaked or changed their project idea because they really hadn't thought through their idea before and realized that they were not passionate about it. For those kids, they learned that the search is one of the most important parts of the project.

The Idea Showcase was validating for the kids and it's validating for us as teachers. What the visitors shared was that the kids were in command of their own learning and seemed excited to be pursuing learning about which they are passionate. The kids got to have positive interactions with adults who were both inquisitive and complementary. They came out of the showcase more confident and assured that their projects were worthwhile and valued. We, as teachers, again saw that kids can really do great things when we get out of their way.

Photos from the Idea Showcase