Showing posts with label Barcelona. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barcelona. Show all posts

Wednesday, 30 September 2015

Open warfare #eden15

It was good to sit Martin Weller in the hot seat recently, for a forthright discussion about various aspects of openness in education. Martin is well known for his work around digital scholarship and his various research into the use of MOOCs and other open education approaches at the British Open University. I caught up with him in Barcelona at the 2015 summer EDEN Conference, where he had just given a keynote speech entitled 'The Battle for Open.' I originally interviewed him via text for this blog post ahead of conference, so many were already aware of what he would be saying. Subsequently, I also posted a live blog of his speech as he stepped off the stage at the event. The video of his keynote will be made available soon on this site, but below is some additional content in the form of the video interview.

The key premise of Martin's presentation was that although openness is now more mainstream and accepted in education than it was previously, there are still small battles to decide the direction and development of openness in the coming years. I asked him about the future of MOOCs and other open courses, and we also discussed the concept of open scholarship. These, and several other related topics made this encounter into what I hope you will agree, is an engaging and thought provoking interview about the importance of open education, and the critical role open content, open courses and open scholarship will play in shaping the future.


Video produced by the European Distance and Elearning Network

Creative Commons License
Open warfare by Steve Wheeler was written in Plymouth, England and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

Monday, 15 June 2015

Sun, Sangria and Spanish flies

It was a lot of fun to be in Barcelona at the same time as Doug Belshaw, Martin Weller, Audrey Watters and several other members of my PLN. We were there for two different, overlapping conferences and it was too good a chance to miss. So, one evening as the sun was setting, a whole bunch of us ended up  down a side street in a tapas bar enjoying the culinary delights of the Catalan capital.

After a few glasses of sangria we began regaling each other with our stories. At one point someone asked us all to say what was the worst job we'd ever had. When it came to my turn, I thought back to my late teens and the summer holiday I had spent earning a little extra cash to see me through my college course.

I had managed to get a holiday job working in a large canning factory, and learnt a lot about how canned and bottled goods were produced. I remember watching as lemonade was bottled. I was quite surprised. After an hour of bottling the most expensive brand of lemonade, a bell sounded and the production team switched labels and started bottling a budget version. It was the same lemonade, just different shaped bottles and different labels. And a very different price.

One morning I was tasked, without any training and with minimal instructions, to work on the marmalade production line. My job was to take the huge cans of orange pulp that had arrived from Spain, lift them onto an automatic can opener, press a button that took the top off, and then dump the contents into a large vat on wheels. When about 20 cans had been dumped into the vat, it was wheeled off, and another took its place. Then the process began again. It was mind numbingly boring... until the moment I lifted a relatively light can up onto the can opening machine.

I thought it was rather strange that it was not as heavy as the others, but because no-one had told me any differently, I carried on. I pressed the button on the can opener and the machine deftly removed the top ... and then .... shock horror! Several thousand flies swarmed out in a huge black cloud and began angrily buzzing around the factory. It was an event of biblical proportions. Within seconds panic had spread. Grown men and women were running screaming from the building. It was absolute mayhem.

The management were forced to shut down the factory for a full 24 hours so it could be completely disinfected. We were all sent home on full pay. The incident of the Spanish flies cost the factory owners a full day of production and I was never asked to work on that part of the production process again. No-one ever blamed me for the debacle, because I had received no training on the job.

The moral of this story? Derek Bok was right. If you think training is expensive, try ignorance.

Photo by Christopher Lynn on Flickr

Creative Commons License
Sun, Sangria and Spanish flies by Steve Wheeler was written in Plymouth, England and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

Wednesday, 10 June 2015

Still, Watters runs deep #EDEN15

Audrey Watters and Maarten de Laat
Education writer and journalist Audrey Watters describes herself as a recovering academic, serial dropout and rabble rouser - her blog also carries the epithet 'trouble maker'. Her involvement in the Hack Education movement derives from her dissatisfaction with current school regimes and her outspoken criticism of traditional education practices has led to her championing alternative education movements such as the flipped classroom, MOOCs and open courseware - and of course, the use of digital learning technologies.

It was therefore with great anticipation that delegates at the 2015 EDEN Conference in Barcelona, gathered to hear her speak. But was she preaching to the converted? Watters certainly modelled the themes of the EDEN Conference - the challenges of expanded learning scenarios. In her speech entitled 'Learning Networks, not Teaching Machines', she talked about the the century old efforts to modernise education and attempts to integrate technology, and then discussed the ideology around networks and learning.

Villemard, c 1910
She used a quote from David Golumbia: 'The network map is not the politcal territory' which traced the word 'network' back to the introduction of the railroads in America, the word now relates to the way people connect and communicate using digital media. Educational technology is not new, she said, but we must avoid purposeful reinterpretation of history. One of the first institutions that was networked was the university, which was the first subscriber to the Internet. She is concerned about embracing globalisation if it actually means the Googlisation of humanity. She showed the famous slide of education 2000, painted by the French artist Villmard, and used it to erroneous interpretation of what technology can achieve. It confirms our beliefs and worst fears that the future of education will be mechanised, and about content delivery, where knowledge is something that must be 'put into' students heads, and reminds us that with each subsequent innovation, we maintain the more traditional, but increasingly irrelevant vestiges of education. More images by Villmard were used to represent content primacy, at the expense of true pedagogy.

Villemard, c 1910
And yet, the students in Villmard's image are actually networked. They are connected by wires to the grinder that dispenses knowledge. They are not isolated from each other in the way the viewer of Edison's film projector is. They are still the recipients of knowledge rather than the transmitters we now know them to be. The web is not distributed evenly, said Watters, and there are many injustices found within it.  We must think about building our technology on the old networks - they don't go away, they are vestiges that remain. We are building our new learning networks on pre-existing and emerging monopolies. This is the political dimension we often conveniently ignore. The control of the network matters. we have to pay attention to the networks - the physical infrastructure and not just the metaphor of the network. Who controls the data? she asked, as this is a question that will increasingly impact upon networked education. Despite the promises we hear that the internet is going to democratise knowledge and learning, we should know that in reality the networks are controlled by massive commercial interest, she warned.

We still think about broadcasting content to people in mass education contexts, Watters complained. This is technological imperialism, she said, and a radical change in pedagogical ideology is required before we will see any true changes in education. When we invoke learning network today, it is naive to think it is not influenced by commercialism. She even went was far as to predict that the web as we now know it will likely be replaced by something else. There is a battle over who controls the network, she said, and educators need to make sure that we build networks in which equity and justice can thrive and be nurtured.

This was a very thoughtful and challenging keynote presentation. She may have left academia behind, but still, Watters runs deep.

Audrey's original notes can be found at this site.

Photo by Steve Wheeler

Creative Commons License
Still, Watters runs deep #EDEN15 by Steve Wheeler was written in Barcelona, Spain and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.

Monday, 16 March 2015

10Q: Martin Weller - the battle for open

Now and then, I have the privilege to interview some great thought leaders in the field of education. I usually feature them on this blog under the banner of 10Q - ten questions. This time, I'm very happy to interview two of the keynote speakers for the EDEN 2015 conference, which will be held in Barcelona. In a few days I'll post my interview with Jim Groom, but first, here's the conversation that ensued when I caught up with The British Open University's Martin Weller.

1)      You’re currently professor of educational technology at the British Open University. What first attracted you to working in education/teaching/research, and why are you still there?

I joined the OU in 1995 just as the web was taking off. It was a very exciting time, as we were exploring the possibility of using the internet, particularly in distance education.  My field was ArtificialIntelligence, but I started experimenting with online tutor groups, producing web pages, etc and migrated into educational technology (as many people did). I chaired the OU's first big elearning course in 1999 with 12,000 students which really demonstrated the potential for elearning. I've stayed in it because it changes a lot and there are always new developments, eg I've been through VLEs, web 2.0, blogs, social media, learning objects, OERs, MOOCs, etc in this period.

2)      You wrote a book on being a digital scholar in 2011. What is digital scholarship, and why is it so important for educators?

 I see digital scholarship as a shorthand really for the intersection between digital technology, the internet and open practice. The intersection of these three offers many opportunities for changes in every aspect of scholarly practice. In the book I took Boyer's 1990 categorisation of scholarship as being discovery, integration, application and teaching, and demonstrated how each of these scholarly functions could be transformed by digital scholarship.

3)      In your experience, how has education changed over the last ten years – and have those changes been good?

I think it's a good news, bad news story. Sometimes it can seem that not much has changed and education (higher education in particular, which is my area of focus) has been very slow to realise the potential of new technologies. Sometimes this is appropriate, for instance not getting swept up in the latest silicon valley hype, but other times it's just a dismissal of any change. But I think this can underestimate a lot of the change that has taken place. It's gradual, and occurs alongside traditional practices - so we still have lectures and campus universities, which might lead you to think nothing much has changed, but parallel with this the role of blended and elearning has become mainstream practice. And we've seen a lot of innovation in the area of open education.

As to whether it's a good thing or not, I've just written a whole book exploring some of this in The Battle for Open, so it's difficult to say in a short answer. Generally I think the use of new tech has allowed education to be more flexible, and opened it up beyond the traditional notion of what constituted a university student. But there has also been some terrible hype about new developments, and technology can also been seen as a route for commercial interests to undermine the role of the university. So, it's a mixed picture. 

4)      Open online provision of courses has seen a surge in popularity around the globe with Openlearn, Futurelearn, and others. Will the bubble burst, or will this momentum be sustained? What are the success factors?

I think the hype is definitely over. But that is often when things get interesting. I think many MOOCs (and MOOC providers) will struggle to find a sustainable financial model in their current guise. But also the genie is out of the bottle in some respects. We will see them adapted and modified, but what the MOOC interest has done is raise the profile of open education and elearning in general, so increasingly universities and governments will look to this as a model.

5)      What is your response to the criticism of MOOCs (e.g. large scale dropouts, superficial learning)?

I think it is easy to be snobbish about MOOCs. It's nearly always a good thing to have people engaged with learning - it's better than having a population sitting around watching reality TV for instance. But equally the MOOC proponents have to take those criticisms seriously. MOOC dropouts are a real issue - at the Open University we've known for a long time that students really require a lot of support if they are to succeed. This is particularly true of the sort of learners you might want to reach with MOOCs (people who cannot access normal higher education for instance). If MOOCs are only good for experienced learners then they won't offer much of a solution.

6)      There has been at least 20 years of research into online learning, and over 40 years of research into distance education. How much of this is relevant to MOOCs, or are they a game changer?

They're a game changer in that they have made people who make decisions and have funding pay attention, but in teaching and learning terms they offer very little that we didn't know already. Apart from some of the more experimental ones that employ connectivist or rhizomatic approachesfor instances, they are fairly limited in terms of pedagogy. It has been mildly entertaining to see many of the MOOC companies making 'discoveries' of things that we have known for ages (eg that students require support). But I think they have raised the profile of elearning, particularly with the entrance of prestigious universities into the area, and that changes the whole landscape.

7)      What do you think will be the next big thing in education? Will we see something new that will transform the learner experience, or simply more of the same?

I don't do predictions anymore! I think it's been a while since we've had a real 'big thing'. MOOCs made a lot of noise, but compared with the impact of the web 2.0/social media developments of the late 00s this was quite small scale. I think we are entering a phase of many different technologies becoming more sophisticated and more integrated into education eg mobile learning, social media, learning analytics. 

8)      What three things should educators be made aware of right now?

I think the general move to openness - MOOCs, OERs, open access, digital scholarship, open data - all these things are part of a bigger picture.  Related to this the nature of academic identity online, and how that relates to traditional practice. Analytics - good and bad uses of this.

9)      What will be the main theme(s) of your keynote at EDEN Barcelona?

I'm going to explore some of the issues around the battle for openness.  

10)   What gets you out of bed in the morning?

My two dogs need to go out the back garden and let me know :)


I feel very fortunate to be in a field (educational technology) and living through a period that it witnessing such rapid and large scale change. Regardless of what you think of MOOCs for instance it was fascinating to watch how they came from nowhere and saw such rapid growth, and then criticism. Being able to both participate in this field and be a recorder, researcher of it is exciting.

Read Martin's blog, the EdTechie.

Photo courtesy of Martin Weller

This interview is mirrored on the EDEN Conference Website

Creative Commons License
10Q: Martin Weller by Steve Wheeler is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.