Showing posts with label failure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label failure. Show all posts

Saturday, 4 July 2015

Never give in!

It is said that Robert the Bruce once sat in a cave watching a spider as it attempted to spin its web. While in exile and hiding after a defeat at the hands of the English, he was inspired by the small arachnid as it tried time and time again, and never gave up. Whether Robert the Bruce was actually inspired by watching a spider spinning its web I know not.  But I can see how such a spectacle could be turned into inspiration.

Inspiration to try again comes from many sources. The great wartime leader Sir Winston Churchill gave a famous speech when Britain was at one of the lowest ebbs in its history, when it seemed that a Nazi invasion was imminent. His speech had echoes of the stirring speech in Shakespeare's Henry V before the battle of Agincourt. One of Churchill's inspirational lines was:

“Never give in. Never give in. Never, never, never, never — in nothing, great or small, large or petty— never give in, except to convictions of honour and good sense. Never yield to force. Never yield to the apparently overwhelming might of the enemy.”

Churchill was nothing if not inspiring. His rhetoric spurred on countless members of the armed forces and civilians to fight against all odds and never give up. That was one of the key reasons why, against overwhelming odds, the British managed to defeat a better equipped, more powerful foe.

Seeing the unseeded players doing battle with the elite tennis stars this week at Wimbledon was a real lesson in perseverance for anyone who watched. They had nothing to lose, and in some cases, actually triumphed. Dustin Brown (a lowly 102 in the world professional rankings) defeated Rafael Nadal, winner of 14 grand slam titles. Yesterday at Wimbledon, Britain's Heather Watson (ranked 109 in the world) came within two points of defeating world number one Serena Williams. You can bet she will come back stronger next time, knowing that she can go toe to toe with the very best in the world and not be embarrassed. No matter how hard or deep the failure, we should never stop thinking about tomorrow.



No matter what anyone tells you, failure is not the end. It is just the start of finding better ways to do something well, as long as you don't give in. We all experience disappointment in our lives. It is how we deal with that disappointment that tells the world about our character. I personally believe that my own failures and disappointments have made me a better teacher. I can empathise with my students when they don't do as well as they had wished, and I can point out to them that it is not the end when they fail. It is simply another opportunity to reflect on their performance and discover what they have to do next time to improve or succeed. Victory after a series of defeats is much sweeter.

If you are fighting a bear, you don't quit when you are tired. You quit when the bear is tired.

Photo by Tom Burke on Wikimedia Commons

Creative Commons License
Never give in! by Steve Wheeler was written in Plymouth, England and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License. NB: This post in a previous version was first published in 2011.

Thursday, 28 May 2015

Devil in the detail

So psychologist Guy Claxton believes that erasers are an instrument of the devil. I can understand why he thinks so. After all, erasers (or to use a term that Americans titter over - rubbers), cover up a multitude of sins. Children can quite easily work their way through a problem, erasing their mistakes as they go, and end up with a seemingly perfect piece of work. Claxton believes that erasers 'create a culture of shame about error' and believes it promotes dishonesty. OK, so this very much sounds like a storm in a teacup and a seemingly trivial battle to fight when there are much more important areas of concern to engage with in education. And yet, some would argue that Claxton has made an important point. Students can, and should, learn through their errors, and sometimes, showing a full working of a problem complete with errors, has a certain pedagogical power. Should errors be covered up? Students should sometimes be given permission to fail, because in so doing they learn how to do something better the next time. I wrote about this some months ago when I bemoaned the fact that only children's perfect pieces of art are seen on display in school reception areas. Little Sarah's picture looks wonderful, but you don't get to see the five previous, crap attempts she made to paint that beautiful swan. The school celebrates the product of her learning, but conveniently hides the messy process.

But if we start banning erasers from schools, what then do we do with computers? Will we need to remove the delete and backspace keys on all the keyboards in the ICT Suite? Do we need to deprive students of the provisionality that all wordprocessors offer? There would be Hell to pay if we did. After all, the ability to continually iterate versions of text or image is part of the creative process. Even better if each version can be preserved to be shown as a process of discovery or creativity that is equally valued alongside the finished product.

Clearly it is nonsense to ban any technology, even simple tools such as erasers, just because they seem to pose some threat to authentic learning. The product is important but so is the process, so why can't both be celebrated equally, and the technologies that brought our students to the point of success not acknowledged? Erasers, just like pencils, computers, whiteboards, sugar paper and pinboards, all have a role to play in the education of our students. The best teachers know that each resource should be used wisely for specific purposes, and none should be overused. There are often simple solutions to the complex problems academics raise. So for now, let's not ban the eraser, but if you insist, perhaps you should ask your students to work their problems through in indelible ink? The devil is in the detail.

Photo by Alex Morfin on Wikimedia Commons

Creative Commons License
Devil in the detail by Steve Wheeler was written in Liberec, Czech Republic and is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.